Home Journalism More Artificial Information (AI) part two

More Artificial Information (AI) part two

0
5
The Eye
Latest posts by The Eye (see all)
“I’ll write this story myself, not using technology to do it for me!”

For our Editor, Welshman Phil Parry, it has always been vital to keep up with current trends, as well as controversies, and now comes more evidence about one of the biggest of all – Artificial Intelligence (AI) – amid growing concern that we may be being deceived by politicians who use AI.

 

There are worries now that even our democracy is being subverted.

New research has shown that a lot of speeches, and other events, are actually generated by AI.

How much is handed over by AI?

An investigation by The Economist has found that one in 10 of the words spoken in debates at the UK Parliament are drafted by AI, and that share is rising, from near-zero in 2024.

It could be more, because most MPs are unwilling to fess up.

One MP, a quarter of whose speeches appear to be AI-written, denied using the technology altogether at work, and added that he and his parliamentary assistant “do have a bit of a running joke, though, that his writing style often uses some of the AI-generated tropes”.

How many speeches here come from AI?

The UK Parliament is not alone either, and, to be perfectly honest we simply do not know how many speeches in the Welsh Parliament/Senedd Cymru (WP/SC), or other constituency work comes from AI, but it is likely to be significant.

In English-speaking legislatures, the heaviest AI-users are Australian and Canadian MPs, whose speeches get flagged (as possibly AI-generated) at triple the rate of British ones.

The House of Lords is worse

Members of the House of Representatives (HoR) in the United States of America (USA) are not far behind.

Across the pond, the House of Lords (HoL) despite its fusty reputation, in fact uses more AI than the House of Commons (HoC).

The lowest-AI chambers sampled in their investigation were the New Zealand House and USA Senate.

Tom Giffard used AI

So where does that leave the WP/SC?

We do know that firm evidence of this practice emerged three years ago with one Member of the Sebedd (MS), but what we don’t know is how much happens NOW.

In 2023 Welsh Conservative (WC) MS Tom Giffard used Chat GPT to write a speech congratulating Wales for winning the World Cup of Darts, admitting the speech ended a little oddly when he declared “long live darts“.

“long live darts”

This tool, from OpenAI, is trained on information from the internet and can answer questions from users.

In a 90-second statement in the WP/SC, Mr Giffard said the team of Gerwyn Price and Jonny Clayton “showed incredible skill, nerve and teamwork throughout the tournament”.

He defended himself by alleging that he made the speech “to show just how advanced the technology is becoming”, and he told the WP/SC it was written with the software.

Mr Gifford declared: “The fact the AI could write a whole speech that can be delivered in a Parliament shows the potential of the technology, as well as the potential pitfalls for future legislators.”

Good reading material…

‘Potential pitfalls’ is right – both for an investigative journalist like me (when evidence might be fake because it was created by AI), and for democracy itself…

 

The memories of Phil’s decades-long award-winning career in journalism as he was gripped by the rare disabling condition Hereditary Spastic Paraplegia (HSP), have been released in a major book ‘A GOOD STORY’ (which was NOT written by AI!). Order it now!