- Independent news - 29th April 2024
- Judge and jury… - 26th April 2024
- From Russia without love… - 25th April 2024
Disturbing revelations in the news today that the widow of a man who took his own life in the enormous Post Office (PO) scandal has yet to receive any payout, again shines the spotlight on the huge role of Wales in the controversy.
Jayakanthan Sivasubramaniam killed himself when officials incorrectly raided his post office branch but his widow has been refused a penny in compensation by the PO, despite them admitting that a flawed ‘audit’ had led to his suicide.
Hundreds of people who owned and operated post offices were wrongly investigated, prosecuted and convicted between 1999 and 2015 because of bugs in a computer system (or unauthorised access by individuals), and it is widely considered one of the gravest miscarriages of justice in British history.
One former sub-postmistress, Seema Misra, spent four months in jail, before she was completely exonerated. She was one of more than 700 people who were falsely accused of stealing money, with 165 going to prison, and it has been blamed for causing at least four suicides.
A campaign in support of all the innocent people, and highlighting the role of executives at the Post Office (PO), was led by a former postmaster from Wales (although born in Liverpool), and a four-part drama about the terrible events was transmitted on ITV (it can still be seen on catch-up), which was filmed largely in North Wales. The series was called ‘Mr. Bates vs The Post Office‘.
The drama followed the story of Alan Bates, who along with his wife Suzanne Sercombe, used life savings in 1998 to buy a PO branch in Llandudno.
An inquiry into the scandal which resumed this week featured heavily in the press, with Mr Bates making front page news.
The Daily Mirror reported yesterday: ‘ALAN Bates electrified the Horizon IT inquiry describing his war with “thugs in suits running the Post Office”‘.
Mr Bates refused to accept liability like many other sub-postmasters and sub-postmistresses, yet executives terminated their contract with just three months’ notice. It meant the couple lost the £65,000 they had invested.
A media outlet publicising the show, reported how the PO have said that they are sorry, and declared: “We sincerely apologise to victims for the devastating impact of the Post Office Horizon IT scandal on the lives of so many”.
A key player at the PO then was Angela van den Bogerd. She too featured in the broadcast and, along with the head of the organisation, Paula Venells (an ordained Priest), was described as part of “the gruesome twosome!”.
Ms van den Bogerd was named afterwards as ‘Head of People’ at the Football Association of Wales (FAW).
Her arrival led to the abrupt departure of the organisation’s contentious chief at the time, who left losing a vote of no-confidence, following an astonishing civil war inside the FAW, which has never been fully explained by the mainstream media.
Ms van den Bogerd’s appointment came despite the fact that she had been found by a judge earlier to have “obfuscated” and “misled” a court, and she is shown in the drama in tears as she reads the judgement.
Ms van den Bogerd was an integral part of the PO’s complaints and mediation scheme, and in 2015 she appeared before MPs at a parliamentary select committee inquiry into the Horizon computer system at the centre of it all (which played a part in the show too). She has also co-authored at least one internal PO report on its relationship between sub-postmasters and mistresses, and that system, while in 2018 she was made ‘Business Improvement Director’. Ms van den Bogerd has now departed the FAW as well.
The Eye’s disclosure of crucial facts like these, came amid news that one sub-postmaster who lived between Swansea and Merthyr Tydfil explained how he (along with others) had tried to take his own life (which Mr Sivasubramaniam sadly did successfully), while another Welshman talked about his marriage going on the rocks.
The Postal Services Minister at the time Paul Scully MP unveiled a further £19.5 million in compensation, taking the total amount of public cash to be paid out to around £30 million, but there is mounting concern that many have yet to receive any money.
Mark Kelly, who ran the Brondeg Post Office, from 2003 until 2006, has like others described publicly the terrible impact on him, of the wrongful accusation from the PO that he had stolen money. He said that it had “made me feel guilty and depressed, over the years, I started then to blame myself and I tried to end my life a few times”.
But Mr Kelly is not alone in having these suicidal thoughts because of the incorrect allegations.
Another former PO worker, Jennifer O’Dell, said she had also considered killing herself and suffered from recurring night terrors. She had been wrongly accused of stealing almost £10,000 from a post office in Cambridgeshire.
Speaking at the end of the first week of the independent inquiry into what happened, Ms O’Dell said she had researched how to take her own life, and suffered from depression and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).
The inquiry (led by retired Welsh judge Sir Wyn Williams) was to hear evidence about the design of the defective Horizon computer system which made the mistakes (or allowed the unauthorised access), as well as the failings in the investigation.
The system’s aim was to replace paper in the network of 17,000 branches – however soon after it was rolled out, shortfalls began to appear, often of several thousand pounds. Problems meant it looked like money was missing from branches when it wasn’t.
Horizon was supplied by the giant Japanese company Fujitsu, but in all there were 736 unsafe convictions for theft, fraud and false accounting. Ms Vennells, who was Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the PO from 2012 to 2019, has been stripped of her CBE, and has put the blame squarely on Fujitsu.
Mr Bates (who was played by star actor Toby Jones), is depicted in the broadcast finding it depressing as he reads a report that she has been given the honour originally for her “services to the Post Office”.
Mr Kelly, who was one of those accused between 2000 and 2014, said: “I can’t really socialise as much as I used to and I can’t actually manage some tasks – I can’t handle stress”.
He has described how he went to senior managers at the organisation, believing he had worked out how the errors were happening, but he said the company “didn’t want to know” and wanted to “bury it”.
He eventually resigned, losing the business and then his house, and it meant he and his wife decided not to start a family. He proclaimed: “We originally hoped to keep the office going and we would start a family – it was a four-bedroom house. But after the breakdown, we lost the house from it all, we thought we couldn’t have a family ’cause we had no house and no stability”.
Mr Kelly, who now runs a mobile phone repair and accessory shop in Neath Market, hopes his story will “help everyone”.
A further victim of the PO’s tactics, Tim Brentnall, from Roch in Pembrokeshire, said the scandal led to the breakdown of his marriage because of “trust issues”, and he was prosecuted in 2010 after a £22,000 ‘shortfall’ was discovered at his branch, but his conviction was overturned.
Mr Brentnall has told how his sister, who ran a local hotel at the time, was also affected because “people tarred her with the same brush”. And he said in the years that followed his conviction, there was a “whispering campaign”, in the community with people calling him a “thief” and a “fraudster”.
Following the overturning of his convictions, he is now working in the Roch shop again, but said the business would never recover financially with its turnover down from £500,000 to £100,000.
In addition to apologising, the PO stated: “In addressing the past, our first priority is that full, fair and final compensation is provided and we are making good progress”.
It may not sound like ‘good progress’ to all those who have considered taking their own lives or unfortunately did so like Mr Sivasubramaniam, when PO compensation payouts to the families have been refused.
Yet at least it shines a spotlight on the role of people in Wales…
The memories of our Editor, Welshman Phil Parry’s, remarkable decades long award-winning career in journalism as he was gripped by the incurable neurological disabling condition Hereditary Spastic Paraplegia (HSP), have been released in a major book (including looking behind the headlines of important events) ‘A GOOD STORY’. Order the book now!
Regrettably publication of another book, however, was refused, because it was to have included names.
Tomorrow – how a controversial picture of the Deputy Leader of Welsh Labour apparently asleep in the House of Commons has caused outrage online, with one critic saying: “This is really awful. To think I pay her wages”.
