- One out all out - 20th November 2026
- Axle grease - 19th November 2026
- The shock of the new… - 19th November 2026

Throughout 43 years in journalism it has never ceased to amaze our Editor, Welshman Phil Parry, how politicians would offer simple solutions to enormously complicated problems – and this is now highlighted by the leader of the opposition’s consistent condemnation of the European Union (EU), particularly her pledge to pull out of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), which could have huge knock on effects.
It’s a bit like a game of ‘jenga’.
You take one block out and the whole thing collapses.

I have thought this time and time again, when politicians make simple promises to solve extremely complicated problems.
You are seeing this now with the opposition of Kemi Badenoch to the European Union (EU), especially her pledge to pull out of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), and requiring all her parliamentary candidates to support this.
The fact is that these issues are massively complicated.
It may, for example, affect Whitehall’s relationship with the devolved nations, and could have other immense ramifications.

The party in power in Wales, Plaid Cymru (Plaid) has long been supportive of the EU.
Last month its leader in the Commons, Liz Saville Roberts said she would welcome any commitment by Andy Burnham to reverse Brexit, claiming Wales would be better off in the political and economic bloc. She has declared that the party is “not afraid to be bold” in campaigning to return to the EU.
Speaking to BBC Wales, Ms Saville Roberts said: “We are firmly in the belief… that Wales has just lost out. We’ve lost out in terms of funding, we’ve lost out in terms of power. For small nations such as Wales, we are better served by being members of a larger union such as the EU.”


But Ms Badenoch is totally opposed, and leaving the ECHR may sound attractive to some, but it is far from simple. EU diplomats suggest she may not have thought through the consequences.
It is not just the embarrassment of the UK, a creator of the ECHR, joining Belarus and Russia as the only European countries outside it, but more seriously, ECHR membership is assumed in both the post-Brexit Trade and Co-operation Agreement (TCA) and the Windsor Framework (WF) that softens the customs border between Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
It is also in the Good Friday Agreement.

Some Tories argue that other EU countries dislike the ECHR, and especially the court that enforces it. But disapproval and withdrawal are different matters.
A forthcoming paper by the Centre for a Better Britain, a think-tank linked to Reform UK, outlines various options for scrapping all post-Brexit EU treaties, identifying which can be expected to trigger retaliation.
One such is pulling out of the ECHR.
The most likely response to ECHR withdrawal would be scrapping the WF and the TCA as a whole – in effect implementing a version of Brexit so hard that even Boris Johnson avoided it in 2020.

There are other things, too, that could have a huge effect, which hasn’t been outlined to voters.
Ms Badenoch has proclaimed her support for Conservative peer Lord Hannan (a passionate Euro-sceptic), and has said: “Recent weeks have seen a bizarre push…to rejoin the EU customs union”.
She may think it bizarre, and is opposed to rejoining, but a lot of business people, who employ a great many people are in favour.
So it is always worth looking at what politicians actually MEAN when they make these easy promises.
Remember that game of jenga…

The memories of Phil’s incredible decades long award-winning career in journalism (when he would often listen open-mouthed as politicians vowed to do something which was undeliverable), as he was gripped by the rare disabling condition Hereditary Spastic Paraplegia (HSP), have been released in a major book ‘A GOOD STORY’. Order the book now!










