Home Culture Conspiracy of fools…

Conspiracy of fools…

0
83
The Eye
Latest posts by The Eye (see all)
“I bet there’ll be a conspiracy theory about what has happened here…”

As a journalist for 43 years, for our Editor, Welshman Phil Parry, conspiracy theories, where ‘information’ is presented without evidence, such as fake moon landings, have been hugely problematic, and this is now underlined by three new books about them.

 

Conspiracy theories seem to be everywhere at the moment, and becoming worse.

Let’s look, for example, at comments from Robert F Kennedy Junior, who is United States Secretary of Health and Human Services – so is an enormously important figure in the field of health policy.

He denies he is anti-vaccine, but one of his main claims – repeated in a 2023 interview with Fox News, was that “autism comes from vaccines”.

This theory was popularised by discredited UK doctor Andrew Wakefield.

But Wakefield’s 1998 study was later retracted by the Lancet medical journal. Multiple studies since, across many countries, have concluded there is no link between vaccines and autism.

At a grilling before the US House Ways and Means Committee, Mike Thompson, a Democrat from California, said to Mr Kennedy Jr: “Your dangerous conspiracy theories are undermining safe and effective vaccines’.

Mr Kennedy Jr was strongly opposed to restrictions during the Covid-19 pandemic, and said at a media event in a video posted by the New York Post, that “Covid-19 is targeted to attack Caucasians and black people. The people who are most immune are Ashkenazi Jews and Chinese”. But health specialists say these claims are false and that the virus does not target any specific ethnic group.

Mike Thompson said they were dangerous conspiracy theories

Then there is his attitude to adding traces of fluoride to drinking water.

Fluoride – a naturally occurring mineral recognised to protect teeth against decay – is added to water supplies in many countries, including the US, where around 63 per cent of the population have fluoridated water.

Mr Kennedy Jr has long campaigned against the practice, and claimed in a recent post on X, that Donald Trump, as President, would be advising ”all US water systems to remove fluoride from public water”.

In his post on X, Mr Kennedy Jr said fluoride was “associated with arthritis, bone fractures, bone cancer, IQ loss, neurodevelopmental disorders, and thyroid disease”.

But Prof Avijit Banerjee, chair of Cariology and Operative Dentistry at King’s College London, said “the potential harmful effects of fluoride cited have not been associated with the very low levels of fluoride used in water fluoridation programmes”.

It appears that the views of Mr Kennedy Jr may be harmful for someone in his position, but at an even more extreme level there is the conspiracy theorist David Icke.

David Icke tells everyone about shape shifters

He contends that the universe consists of “vibrational” energy and infinite dimensions sharing the same space, and argues that there is an inter-dimensional race of reptilian beings, the ‘Archons’ or ‘Anunnaki’, who have hijacked the planet.

Further, Mr Icke says that a genetically modified human–Archon hybrid race of reptilian shape-shifters – the Babylonian Brotherhood, Illuminati or “elite” – manipulate events to keep humans in fear, so that the Archons can feed off the resulting “negative energy”.

He claims that many public figures belong to the Babylonian Brotherhood and propel humanity towards a global fascist state or New World Order, a post-truth era ending freedom of speech, and that the only way to defeat such “Archontic” influence is for people to wake up to the truth and fill their hearts with love.

Indeed ridiculous stuff about the Illuminati is investigated in a new book with just this as its title, and it highlights the difficulty in countering such conspiracy theories for journalists like me.

All the evidence in the world can be brought to bear in debunking such views, but conspiracy theorists might just say: “Ah, but that’s all fake news, which has been planted by the Archons”.

‘Illuminati‘ is by the historian Michael Taylor. The group DID exist, yet far from being an all-powerful circle of string-pullers, they were a bunch of fissiparous nerds.

The Illuminati were founded in Bavaria in 1776 to spread Enlightenment values, and Bavaria’s authorities hounded the group out of existence after barely a decade, but it lived on in the imagination.

In 1797 a reactionary French priest called Augustin Barruel blamed thinkers including Voltaire and Diderot for seeking to destroy Christianity with the help of Freemasons and the Illuminati. Revolutionary terror, he thundered, embodied “the black arts of Illuminism”.

Nesta Webster revived and added to the conspiracy theory

In 1919, more than a century later, Nesta Webster revived Barruel’s mad theory, writing that the “diabolical methods employed by the Jacobins of France, indoctrinated by the Illuminati, have been repeated in Russia with terrible effect”. She added a nasty wrinkle: “a conspiracy of the Jewish race that began perhaps at Golgotha” had, in league with the Illuminati, inspired the French and Russian revolutions, the uprisings of 1848, the Paris Commune of 1871 and the rise of trade unionism.

In ‘The Hidden History of Conspiracy Theory’, by Andrew McKenzie-McHarg, another historian, says two characteristics distinguish conspiracy theories from ordinary rumours or smears. First, they posit plots by the powerful.

People spin conspiracy theories to explain secret forces shaping the world, not, say, why their dishwasher fails to clean properly, and second, they refer “not just to a conspiracy but to a non-existent conspiracy”.

Watergate and the Iran-contra affair, for instance, are infrequent subjects for theorising because they actually happened. (They were also exposed and punished). By contrast, conspiracy theories focus on ‘hidden’ plots.

Nicolas Guilhot writes that conspiracy theories “reflect a diffuse social malaise”

In ‘Conspiracy’ Nicolas Guilhot, a French academic, writes that conspiracy theories “reflect a diffuse social malaise” and frustration with an “obsolescent variety of liberalism”.

The phrase ‘conspiracy theory’ may have first appeared in the New York Times in 1863, in a letter rebutting the charge that Britain was “going out of her way to meddle with America” during the civil war.

But the concept is much older. In the 14th century Jews were accused of spreading the Black Death by poisoning wells.

Many Londoners said Catholics started the Great Fire of London in 1666. “The Protocols of the Elders of Zion”, first published in Russia in 1903, purported to reveal a Jewish plot for world domination.

Good reading material…

These absurd theories emerged at times of social upheaval: wars, pandemics and the crumbling of the old imperial order. They provided simple explanations for complicated events—and a villain to blame.

Just don’t ask me to interview people who believe this nonsense, because they may just say my evidence is fake, and has been planted by the ‘Archons’!

 

The memories of Phil’s astonishing decades long award-winning career in journalism (when there was no social media to publicise conspiracy theories at the start) as he was gripped by the rare disabling condition Hereditary Spastic Paraplegia (HSP), have been released in a different sort of book ‘A GOOD STORY’. Order the book now! 

‘Conspiracy’, by Nicolas Guilhot, with Belknap Press, is $32.95 and £27.95

‘The Hidden History of Conspiracy Theory,’ by Andrew McKenzie-McHarg, with Princeton University Press, is $42.95 and £35

‘Illuminati’ by Michael Taylor, with Liveright, is $35. Bodley Head; £25