Flying into trouble?

The Eye
Latest posts by The Eye (see all)
A difficult walk?

Fears are growing for the controversial link up between the state-owned Qatar Airways (QA) and contentious Cardiff Airport (CA) which may receive another £6.8 million of taxpayers’ money after getting a ‘loan’ of £21.2 million, following news the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the troubled airline warned staff it must “act decisively”The Eye can reveal.

QA has alerted its employees of “substantial” redundancies as it struggles with a collapse in demand during the lockdown, and its CEO Akbar Al Baker wrote to staff warning of future job losses. The airline has said it needed to “act decisively to protect the future of the business”.

Akbar Al Baker – ‘We need to be decisive’

QA employs over 45,000 people and has a fleet of more than 240 planes. A spokesman said: “The unparalleled impact on our industry has caused significant challenges for all airlines”.

But the airline, and the state, have not been without challenges in the past.

Qatar has been the subject of a warning from the UK Government to travellers going there, and holds pariah status among many other nations. Saudi Arabia is one of several countries around the world which have cut off diplomatic relations with the country.

Spencer Birns – ‘We want them to be successful’

The flight to Qatar’s capital Doha from CA was hugely-praised in the mainstream media, despite the fact that the desert emirate has often hit the headlines.

The airport’s Chief Commercial Officer Spencer Birns has stated baldly:  “Qatar Airways are committed to the route (with Doha, Qatar’s capital) and we want them to be successful”.

Roger Lewis, then Chairman of Cardiff Airport (third from left) with Qatar Airways Chief Executive Akber Al Baker, (fourth from left) the Welsh Secretary at the time Alun Cairns (fourth from right) and the Welsh first minister at the time Carwyn Jones (second from right) greeting Qatar Airways

The extraordinary statement came after other remarkable comments.

The Chairman of CA at the time, Roger Lewis described as “transformational” the link with QA.

Meanwhile disturbing headlines have also swirled around Qatar’s other alleged actvities, putting further pressure on the partnership with CA. The UK Government has told potential travellers to the country they faced major risks, and it stated on its advice website:  “Terrorists are likely to try to carry out attacks in Qatar.

Qatar denies supporting groups linked to Islamic State (IS)

Eight sovereign nations around the world have severed diplomatic ties altogether with Qatar and in July 2017 it was reported that the state had been cut off by some of its neighbours over alleged terrorist support. Qatar denies backing groups linked to Islamic State (IS) although it does admit it supports the Muslim Brotherhood.


The emirate had refused to comply with an initial list of 13 demands, saying it would not agree to any measures that threatened its sovereignty or violated international law.

Omar al-Bashir – convicted of corruption

But it was told by its neighbours that they wanted it to accept six broad principles on combating extremism and terrorism.

Qatar also hosted the ousted ruler of Sudan, Omar al-Bashir, who was convicted of corruption in a Sudanese court on December 14 but he seems unlikely to be extradited to stand trial for overseeing genocide in Darfur.

They wanted their President to go

It also kept silent as hundreds of thousands of Algerians protested, chanting “the people want the regime to go”, and hundreds of millions of dollars in ‘aid’ money has too been given by Qatar to Hamas, the group which holds sway in the Gaza Strip, and which has been designated by the USA as a terrorist organisation.

Qatar’s successful football World Cup bid has prompted major questions as well, putting under more strain the relationship with CA. The Sunday Times, has revealed that the tiny desert state had secretly offered £400 million to FIFA just 21 days before the worrying decision was announced to hold the 2022 football World Cup there.

Cardiff Airport – Financially diligent?

CA too has hit the headlines for all the wrong reasons.

It has emerged that Welsh ministers are considering ‘lending’ CA more millions of pounds, although officials had originally requested the huge sum of £28 million.



We were told that the Welsh Government (WG) will carry out “analysis and financial due diligence” before the additional funding is approved, and that the £21.2 million ‘loan’ last year was itself an extension on the £38.2 million the airport could already ‘borrow’ from the WG.

More taxpayers’ money is handed over…

The money follows on from backing for the other multi-million pound ‘loan’ by Welsh ministers, for an airport bought by the taxpayer for £52 million when Glasgow Prestwick cost the Scottish Executive just £1.

But granting the extra money to the Welsh airport has been highly controversial, even after the ‘due diligence’ process, especially in the light of CA’s association with QA.

Welsh Conservative MS Russell George, who speaks on transport issues, said: “This is good money after bad.

Russell George, MS – ‘unsustainable’

“Tot up the purchase price of £52 million, the current £38.2 million loan, and last year’s £21.2 million loan, and the airport could be in hock to the taxpayer to the tune of more than £110 million since it was bought by the government in 2013. This is unsustainable…”

Despite all these controversies, the mainstream media, senior politicians in Wales as well as executives at CA have lauded the connection with QA, and The Eye have been the only Welsh media organisation to report uncomfortable facts about its country.

Carwyn Jones has ‘interesting’ meeting with Qatari

In interviews, the First Minister of Wales at the time, Carwyn Jones MS, stated:  “We would like to work with his excellency (Mr Al Akber).

He tweeted that he “welcomed” the first QA flight into CA and said it represented a “huge boost” for Wales.

The then Welsh Secretary Alun Cairns, MP, informed us:  “The new flight from Cardiff to Doha plugs our entrepreneurs straight into one of the most dynamic economies in the Middle East, and an airport which offers a further 150 global destinations”.

Flights to Doha’s airport were welcomed

The mainstream media’s response to the announcement of the new route at the time was remarkable in its ‘dynamism’, and became a target of our satirical writer Edwin Phillips.

The new flight to Qatar’s Hamed International Airport was described positively in the South Wales Echo as providing “capacity for 150,000 passengers a year, as well as significant freight capacity for Welsh exporters at around 10 tonnes a flight”. In April 2017 BBC Wales’s Economics Correspondent Sarah Dickins said approvingly:  “The new direct route from Cardiff to Doha is a reminder not just that the economy of Qatar is growing significantly but also that trade between Wales, the Arab world and beyond is increasing”.

Roger Lewis – ‘Transformational’

When the first flight from Doha was due, WalesOnline reported faithfully the words of Mr Lewis when he said: “This is a pivotal moment for Cardiff Airport, for Wales and the South West of EnglandThe far reaching consequences of this service for passengers and businesses will be transformational”. The same praising word was used by the present Chief Executive of CA Deb Bowen Rees who told the South Wales Echo:  “The Qatar Airways service has been transformational…”

The National Museum of Wales/Amgueddfa Cenedlaethol Cymru – ‘Tranformational’

It seems the then Chair of CA Roger Lewis has also transformed himself since the tie-up with QA, and a new one has just been announced (see story tomorrow). He is to take on another position as president of the National Museum of Wales/Amgueddfa Cymru.

But he is no stranger to controversies.

Before his tenure at CA, he was fully immersed during a tumultuous period in charge of the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) when his institution engaged in a fierce row with the regions, which he lost.

Did Roger Lewis preside over the dismantlement of departments at ITV Wales?

When he was head of ITV Cymru Wales Mr Lewis also provoked enormous anger – this time among some of his staff. One former employee told us:  He presided over the piecemeal dismantlement of ITV Wales, with facilities and departments disappearing one after another, a process which would eventually lead to the closure of the Culverhouse Cross (CX) site.  I remember there was much ‘management speak’ about the need to move to a facility that was fit for purpose ‘going forward’”.

Dafydd Elis-Thomas – ‘delighted’

Yet despite this chequered history, on his appointment, the Welsh Deputy Minister for Culture Sport and Tourism, Lord Dafydd Elis-Thomas MS, said: “I’m delighted with Roger’s appointment as the new president for Amgueddfa Cymru”.

Mr Lewis too has apparently seen his moves in a positive light and has commented on television in the past:  “I know my success is staggering to many”. Part of that ‘staggering success’ may be that he has also threatened to place a legal injunction on The Eye to stop a previous article about him being published which he did not like, but was effectively only a pull-together of previous statements such as this.

Book posterIt will also be ‘staggering’ to commentators in the Welsh mainstream media as well as politicians, if the connection between CA and QA is axed because the company needs to be ‘decisive’ after they had praised it so much…


Tomorrow – the UK Government ministers who have not performed well during the lockdown, and why the newly-announced Chair of CA may be taking on a ‘poisoned chalice’.

Our Editor Phil Parry’s memories of his astonishing 36-year award-winning career in journalism as he was gripped by the incurable disabling condition Hereditary Spastic Paraplegia (HSP), have been released in a major new book ‘A GOOD STORY’. Order the book now! 

If you need something to keep the children entertained during these uncertain times (in Welsh) try Ffwlbart Ffred about the amusing stories of Ffred and his pet